February16
The Society of Midwives India (SOMI), Indore chapter hosted the “Journey of the Lamp” event this past week.
The SOMI lamp for safe motherhood, a traditional lamp with the SOMI emblem, travels across India, being passed from state to state. While the lamp is in a state, special activities take place to raise awareness and improvement in quality of mother and child services. SOMI states “there is a close link between the terms of motherhood, women-hood and midwifery. Women need midwives, and midwives are themselves women.”
Over fours various educational events took place, including a poster and debate competition. Two nursing students from every college in Indore were invited to participate in each of the competitions. Rashmi (2nd year) and Karin (1st year) participated in the poster competition themed “Healthy Mother – A Key to Future.”
The debate theme was “Utilization of National Health Schemes for the Welfare of Mother and Child.” Two 2nd year students, Sweta arguing for and Paulen arguing against, represented MIBE Graduate School for Nurses. Competing against 14 other contestants Sweta placed 3rd and Paulen placed 1st. When receiving congratulations from staff and students, these women explained how events like this enhances their learning and “motivates nurses to use their skills for their country’s benefit.” Although they took opposing stances, they agree the national maternal and child health schemes are good. Though poor maternal and infant mortality rates persist, “these programs should not be stopped. We should make improvements to them and keep striving to raise the standard of the mother and child,” by providing quality services.
Get in on the debate, by reading their statements…
FOR:
About three quarters of the world’s population lives in developing countries. In the terms of population USA ranks third in the word after India, there is gaining gap of 836 million, between the populations of the world. India accounts for 17.56% of the world’s population and 80% of the Indian population live in rural areas, and 59% of India’s population is pregnant women.
The Alma Ata declaration, in 1978, emphasized “Health for All.” That means health is the right of each and every person in the world. All the national health schemes attempt to provide accessible, affordable, accountable, effective and reliable primary health care.
The children are the most vulnerable group and liable to get various diseases and disabilities which may lead to high mortality rate in this age group. It is, therefore, very important to provide comprehensive health care services to children from conception to childhood to promote their health.
The health of children is also very important not only because they are an asset and the future of their families and nation, but also because health status, health behaviour and lifestyle formed during childhood determine quality of life during the following year of life.
Mothers and pregnant women are a more dependant and vulnerable member of society. They are at high risk of morbidity and mortality. It is also observed that the death of mothers and children are major contributors to mortality in any community in India.
The healthy life of any county depends on the health of child and mother. They are the basic unit of health country. Most of the national schemes are mainly focussing on women and children’s health, such as, ASHA, NRHM, Janani Suraksha Yogna, prophylaxis against nutrition anaemia, special nutrition program, Integrated Child Development Services, Mid-Day Meal Program, and maternal & child Health Program, Child Survival and Safe Motherhood, etc.
Mother and child health refers to a package of comprehensive health care services, which are developed to meet promotive, preventive, curative, rehabilitative needs of pregnant women before, during and after delivery, and infant and preschool children from birth to five years. These services are rendered as mother-baby package because mother and baby are considered as one unit.
As many are raising questions about utilization of these programs and they are focussing on maternal mortality rates (MMR) of 2010, i.e. 450 maternal deaths per 100,000, I agree there is a decline in the statistics. But we have also had good results from 1997 to 2006. As the MMR in 1997 was 408 per 100,000; 2003 was 301 deaths per 100,000; and 2006 was 254 deaths per 100,000.
I do favour these programs, but we need to do some correction to have good results. The MMR of 2010 also denotes that there are many institutional deliveries, women are crossing the customs and boundaries of their home and may be good counting measures of people.
For the bad result we cannot blame the national schemes, but we need to have proper guidance, supervision and also motivate people to utilize the benefits. We need to put out full effort to make it successful. It is our responsibility as health personnel.
The schemes run by the government are excellent. We need to promote the utilization and also do correction to our fault.
“Where there is a will, there is a way.”
AGAINST:
There are several programs which the government has implemented for the welfare of the child and mother like:
-Child Survival and Safe Motherhood Program
- Vande Matran Scheme
- Janani Suraksha Yogna
and many more, but how much are they being utilized?
Approximately 80% of Indian’s population live in rural areas, where there is a lack of health care infrastructure, trained health care workers, drugs, etc. Often only Traditional Birth Attendants are available and they may not be well trained.
The main causes of maternal deaths are severe bleeding and unsafe abortion. It can be seen in the MMR according to
1997 = 408 deaths per 100,000 live births
2001-2003 = 301deaths per 100,000 live births
2004-2006 = 254 deaths per 100,000 live births
2010 = 450 deaths per 100,000 live births
The 1997 MMR, which is 408 per 100,0000 live birth, which means that around 125,000 women die each year due to pregnancy related causes. Now, i.e. 2010’s MMR has increased to 450 per 100,000 live births, which clearly shows that there is not much utilization of the national schemes.
“Health for All” has been declared the standard for all United Nations countries at Alma Ata. But is every child able to attain it?
Globally and nationally the most common problem is low birth weight (LBW). About 50% of all perinatal mortality, 33% of all infant mortality and morbidity are due to LBW.
Infants who survive the perinatal period encounter other easily preventable life threatening challenges. Thirty thousand children under 5 years die due to unsafe drinking water and malnutrition in the state of Madhya Pradesh annually.
This reveals that mothers and their children are unable to utilize the government schemes.
A test of national development is the measure of consideration of the utilization of the facilities.

Debaters, Sweta and Paulen
Congratulations Sweta and Paulen for your thought provoking statements!