The following is a list of ministers known for having served St. James-St. Andrew’s over the years.
| Dates | Name |
|---|---|
| 1862 | Mr. Joshua Fraser |
| 1862-1880 | Student ministers, lay preachers, and travelling missionaries. |
| 1880-1882 | Rev. Charles McLean |
| 1883-1884 | Mr. D. McLean, missionary |
| 1884-1885 | Rev. John McKenzie |
| 1886 | Rev. D. McLean (returned after graduation) |
| 1887-1903 | Rev. D.D. MacLennan (with Apple Hill) |
| 1904-1905 | Rev. George Weir, B.A. (with Avonmore) |
|
|
|
| 1905-1906 | Rev. Hector N. MacLean, B.D., Ph.D. (with Avonmore & Monkland) |
| 1907-1909 (Herbert Hill’s article) or 1906-1908 |
Rev. James Hastie (with Monkland) |
| 1909-1911 | Mr.Andrew Drysdale student minister (with Monkland) |
| 1911-1913 | Mr. Bolingbrook, student minister (with Monkland) |
| 1913 | Mr. D.A. McQuaig, student minister (with Monkland) |
| 1913-1914 | Rev. Isaac Campbell (with Monkland) |
|
|
|
| 1915-1920 | Rev. J.G. MacIvor (with Monkland) |
| 1921-1926 | Rev. T.O. Miller (with Monkland) |
| 1927-1929 | Mr. J.T. MacPherson, student minister (with Monkland) |
| 1930-1932 | Mr. R.M. Magill, student minister (with Monkland) |
| 1933-1935 | Mr. D.M. Kerr, student minister (with Monkland) |
| 1936 | Mr. John Anderson, student minister (with Monkland) |
|
|
|
| 1937 | Rev. Donald MacMillan, M.A. (with Monkland and Avonmore) |
| 1938-1947 | Rev. Malcolm N. MacDonald, (with Monkland and Avonmore) |
| 1948-1955 | Rev. Donald C. MacDonald, (with Monkland and Avonmore) |
| 1955-1961 | Rev. W.A. Douglas, with Monkland and Avonmore) |
| 1963-1967 | Rev. Hugh Wilson, (with Monkland and Avonmore) |
| 1968-1974 | Rev. Willis E. Sayers (with Monkland and Avonmore) |
|
|
|
| 1975-1989 | Rev. John H. Wiseman, (with Monkland and Avonmore) |
| 1990-1998 | Rev. Donald C. MacDonald (with Monkland and Avonmore) |
| 1999-2017 | Rev. Mark Bourgon (with Finch and Avonmore) |
| 2018-2019 | Herb Borger, Student Minister (with Finch and Avonmore) |
| 2019- | Rev. Dr. Cheryl Gaver (with Finch and Avonmore) |